top of page

The Best Hot Sauces for Bloody Marys


The Best Hot Sauces for Bloody Marys

Ah, the Bloody Mary, a drink that's both a hangover cure and a brunch staple. Over the years, this iconic cocktail has evolved, with foodies and mixologists adding their own twists. The story behind this famous drink goes that a young bartender named Fernand “Pete” Petiot created the Bloody Mary at Harry's New York Bar in Paris in 1921.


It has since then evolved with numerous variations and today, hot sauces have become a popular addition, allowing each glass to be tailored to individual tastes.


But with so many options out there, which hot sauces are the best for your Bloody Mary?


Today we're going to talk about the best hot sauces for Bloody Marys, offering you ideas for both your basic name brand hot sauces and some more unique craft hot sauce options that will turn your Bloody Mary into the best thing you've tried since your grandma's homemade apple pie.

bloody mary drink

The Anatomy of a Great Bloody Mary

Before we get into the best hot sauces for Bloody Marys, let's talk about what makes a fantastic Bloody Mary... Because after all, it's not just the hot sauce that makes this drink stand out.


A classic Bloody Mary includes vodka, tomato juice, lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, hot sauce, salt, pepper, and various garnishes like celery, olives, and pickles.


The beauty of this cocktail is its versatility—you can adjust the ingredients to suit your taste. Add, remove, or change up those ingredients to make it slightly different.


Key Components of a Bloody Mary

  • Vodka: The base of the cocktail, providing a neutral background.

  • Tomato Juice: Adds the bulk of the flavor and body.

  • Lemon Juice: Provides acidity and brightness.

  • Worcestershire Sauce: Adds umami and depth.

  • Hot Sauce: Brings the heat and additional flavor complexity (you can skip if using a spicy Bloody Mary Mix.

  • Seasonings: Salt, pepper, and sometimes other spices like celery salt or smoked paprika.

  • Garnishes: Celery, olives, pickles, and even bacon or shrimp for the adventurous.


There are insane Bloody Marys out there with literally everything you can think of in them. But at the core, these are the key components to a great Bloody Mary.

spicy bloody marys

How to Create a Bloody Mary

  1. Mix the Base: Combine vodka, tomato juice, lemon juice, Worcestershire sauce, hot sauce, salt, and pepper in a shaker with ice.

  2. Shake It Up: Shake well to blend all the flavors.

  3. Strain and Pour: Strain the mixture into a glass filled with ice.

  4. Garnish: Add your favorite garnishes for that Instagram-worthy touch.


Ok, now that we have a bit of the history, have the ingredients, and know how to make one, let's talk about what hot sauces to use in a Bloody Mary. We're going to split this into two parts, craft hot sauces for Bloody Marys and name brand hot sauces for Bloody Marys.

The Best Craft Hot Sauces for Bloody Marys

Here are some of the best craft hot sauces that will add incredible flavor and the perfect amount of heat to your Bloody Mary.


Reaper Unleashed

If you want lots of flavor with some serious heat, Mikey V's Reaper Unleashed is your go-to. This sauce features the infamous Carolina Reaper pepper, balanced with a unique flavor profile.


It's not just about melting your face off; it’s about enhancing your Bloody Mary with an intense, flavorful kick. Heat level? A solid 9/10.


Ideal for those who like their drinks hot but flavorful.

reaper unleashed

Ghostly Garlic

Coming in at just over 1 million Scoville heat units, Ghostly Garlic uses the Bhut Jolokia, or Ghost Pepper. Its slightly smoky taste, combined with a rich garlic flavor, makes it a standout in any Bloody Mary.


If you're a garlic lover looking for some serious heat, this one's for you. It adds a layer of complexity that will leave you coming back for more.

ghostly garlic hot sauce

Dill Pickle Reaper Hot Sauce

Nothing pairs better with a Bloody Mary than a pickle... which is why a dill pickle hot sauce is PERFECT for Bloody Marys.


This Dill Pickle Reaper hot sauce brings the tangy goodness of dill pickles and the heat of the Carolina Reaper. It's perfect for a Bloody Mary, adding both spice and a refreshing tang.


Plus, it's versatile enough to enjoy on hot dogs, pizza, and burgers, making it a great addition to your condiment collection.

dill pickle reaper hot sauce

Crack of Don

Inspired by a Navy veteran and hot sauce lover, Crack of Don combines the radiant Yellow Fatalii pepper with sun-ripened crushed pineapple.


This sauce offers a balance of heat and sweetness, creating a burst of flavors that will make your Bloody Mary unforgettable.


It's perfect for those who want a little sweetness with their spice.

crack of don hot sauce

The Best Name Brand Hot Sauces for Bloody Marys

Now that we've gone over some of the best craft hot sauces, let's talk about a few name brands since you can find these in just about any grocery store.


These are the tried and true hot sauces that can be found in most supermarkets, making them easily accessible for those last minute brunch cravings or impromptu hangovers.


Tabasco: The classic, tangy flavor of Tabasco adds a nice kick without overpowering the other flavors in your Bloody Mary. Plus, it comes in small individual bottles, perfect for on-the-go mixing.


Frank's RedHot: Another staple hot sauce that has been around since 1920. Its vinegar-based flavor adds a slight tanginess to your drink while still providing a decent amount of heat.


Cholula: This Mexican-style hot sauce adds a unique flavor to your Bloody Mary, with its blend of arbol and piquin peppers. It's not too hot but still brings in that classic Mexican heat.

spicy bloody mary mix

What to Use Instead of Hot Sauce in a Bloody Mary

If you can't find or don't have access to hot sauce, there are some alternatives you can use in your Bloody Mary that can still make it a spicy cocktail.


These may not be as traditional, but they still add a kick of spice and flavor!


  • Horseradish: Grated horseradish is a classic ingredient in Bloody Marys and adds a sharp, spicy kick.

  • Cayenne Pepper: This spice is commonly used in Cajun cuisine and can add some heat to your drink without overpowering the other flavors.

  • Jalapeño or habanero peppers: Adding a slice of these peppers to your drink can give it a spicy kick and add some visual appeal.

bloody mary with garnish and rim

What's Your Perfect Bloody Mary Hot Sauce?

There you have it—four incredible hot sauces that will elevate your Bloody Mary game. Whether you prefer a smoky garlic kick, the tang of dill pickles, or the sweet heat of pineapple, there's a hot sauce here for you.


But the beauty of a Bloody Mary is that you can always mix and match to create your perfect blend of flavors. Experiment with different hot sauces, add in some horseradish or even bacon-infused vodka—you never know what amazing creation you may come up with.


Let us and the other readers know in the comments what your favorite hot sauce is for the perfect Bloody Mary!

Comments


bottom of page